A defensive strategy called DARVO that is frequently used by accused sexual offenders now is often used by federal immigration agents accused of violence.

Cornell University joins sexual assault Hall of Shame
Regardless of what you think about the much-publicized civil lawsuit claiming that Cornell University failed to protect a student from a gang rape, it’s fair to say that the school has joined a historical Hall of Shame in public opinion.
I’ve been holding off commenting about the suit until the initial media attention starts to wane. See CNN’s timeline of the case if you want a refresher. In addition, New York Focus recently reported on a separate civil suit filed in 2023 claiming that Cornell University’s inaction enabled a male student to sexually abuse two women students and possibly others. That case also is ongoing.

It’s all a bit ironic, since women at Cornell University in the 1970s helped coin the term “sexual harassment” to give a name to common and often socially-accepted behavior by men that discriminated against women in a sexual manner. If you want to learn more about that, read up on the case of Carmita Wood, an administrative assistant who became physically ill from the stress of fending off repeated sexual advances by her boss, a physics professor. Growing recognition of sexual harassment eventually led to greater recognition and understanding of sexual assault and its effects. But I digress.
My contribution to the discussion today about the sexual assault lawsuits at Cornell is to give you a snapshot of the landmark lawsuits and legal fines over sexual assaults in schools and colleges since the federal law known as Title IX outlawed sex discrimination in education in 1972. What you’ll see below is taken straight out of my book Fifty Years of Title IX: How 37 Words Changed America (The New Press, 2026). It’s a curated selection of cases, not a comprehensive list.
The outrage over what happened at Cornell is new, and yet timeless. Read about some of the lawsuits that came before to get a sense of what Cornell, the accused rapists, and their accusers may be facing. And how this is one step further in the movement toward a society in which the Hall of Shame can become solely a thing of history instead of reflecting current practices.
Keep in mind that lawsuits and fines are just part of the movement. The activism around them, education about sexual assault, and both of their effects on policies and politics, are all just as important. But those are topics for another blog post.
Top photo caption: A protest at Cornell University in October 2026 supports “Jane Doe,” the plaintiff in the gang-rape lawsuit. (Credit: John4Numbers, CC0, via Creative Commons).
Sexual assault, 1990s
1992: Wait, what? If Congress passed Title IX in 1972, why does this timeline start in the 1990s? Because before February 26, 1992, the most a student could expect from suing a school over sexual harassment/assault in civil court was a court order for the school to do better, and only if the plaintiff was still in school. Then student Christine Franklin and her mother sued Gwinnett (Ga.) County Public Schools for $11 million after economics teacher and coach Andrew Hill groomed Christine as a sophomore and began raping her, while school officials looked the other way.
Christine was 22 years old and married by the time the case reached the Supreme Court. The Supremes ruled that because Title IX was patterned (nearly word for word) after Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, and since Title VI allowed plaintiffs to collect monetary awards, Title IX should too.
Beyond 1992: After Franklin v. Gwinnett, Title IX lawsuits spiked. Courts decided 24 cases from the end of 1992 to 1995 alone. Probably many more settled to avoid a court ruling. The Berkeley (Calif.) Unified School District in 1994 agreed to pay $1.8 million, for example, to settle a suit claiming that they had refused to remove a music teacher who sexually abused two preteen students. But the district admitted no wrongdoing and kept employing the teacher. That case, Patricia H. v. Berkeley Unified, was the first to establish that students could seek damages for hostile educational environments due to sexual harassment under Title IX, just as Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 prohibits sexually hostile work environments.
1991: In a survey of 2,400 students by the Stanford Rape Education Project, one in three women and one in eight men reported having been pressured into having sex against their will.
1998: The Supreme Court gutted 20 years of jurisprudence regarding sexual harassment in a case involving Texas teacher Frank Walthrop, who made sexually suggestive comments to girls and started fondling and repeatedly raping 14-year-old student Alida Star Gebser. School officials failed to act despite warnings. Police caught Walthrop raping Gebser and arrested him. In Gebser v. Lago Vista Independent School District, the Supremes made it much harder to hold schools responsible for sexual harassment of students than of employees. A school official with the authority to do something about it had to have “actual knowledge” of the discrimination, and the official had to have deliberately failed to respond appropriately, which can be very hard to prove. Gebser lost her case, and a precedent was set.
1999: The Supreme Court for the first time affirmed in Davis v. Monroe County Board of Education that Title IX covers peer harassment, not just assaults by faculty or staff. The case involved a boy who repeatedly harassed 10-year-old Georgia student LaShonda Davis to the point that she contemplated suicide. School officials ignored the pleas of her mother, Aurelia Davis, and of other girls to stop the harassment. The boy eventually pled guilty to sexual battery. The school district settled the case out of court. But the Supreme Court ruling in Davis also weakened Title IX by endorsing a more stringent definition of sexual harassment in education than in employment.
Sexual assault, 2000s
The inaction or even obstructionism of educational institutions became more apparent as survivors of sexual violence and harassment called out the policies that protected perpetrators and failed survivors. Student survivors increasingly highlighted the institutionalized discrimination, not just the harmful actions of the perpetrators.
2002: More than a third (36%) of colleges and universities failed to report statistics on campus crimes and rapes as required by the 1990 Clery Act, a U.S. Department of Justice study found. The law was named after freshman Jeanne Clery, who was raped and murdered in her dorm by study Josoph Henry, one of 38 violent crimes at Lehigh University in Pennsylvania that school officials had kept quiet about. Federal fines for Clery Act violations started to add up: Salem International University in West Virginia paid $200,000; LaSalle University in Pennsylvania paid $87,500; and Eastern Michigan University was fined $350,000, for example.
2000s: The effects of sexual assault on survivors started to become better appreciated. Angela Tezak overdosed on sleeping pills after Penn State University withheld her rapist’s degree for only a year; she dropped out and eventually transferred. Megan Wright dropped out of Dominican College in New York State after being gang-raped and suffering flashbacks while the college essentially did nothing, waiting for police to investigate; she suffocated herself at home with a plastic bag in 2006. Two years later Dominican agreed to appoint a Title IX administrator (which they’d been required to do for more than three decades) and paid a $20,000 fine for fraudulent crime statistics.
A case-control study of 2,005 women who’d been physically or sexually attacked found they were 50%-70% more likely than non-abused women to develop gynecologic or chronic stress-related or central nervous system problems including headaches, back pain, vaginal bleeding or infections, sexually transmitted diseases, pelvic pain, painful intercourse, urinary trace infections, appetite loss, abdominal pain, and digestive problems. Another study of 304 women found higher risk for significant depression, anxiety and poor sleep.
2007: Ten years of legal battles ended when the University of North Carolina agreed to pay $355,000 to students to settle their lawsuit in Jennings v. University of North Carolina, which claimed a sexually hostile environment under Soccer Coach Anson Dorrance. And officials at the University of Colorado, Boulder agreed to pay $2.85 million to settle Simpson v. Univ. of Colo. Boulder, which accused them of creating an environment that led to rapes by five football players and recruits.
2008: An estimated 6,450 students at 26 colleges were sexually assaulted during a six-month period in 2008, based on Department of Justice data, but the schools reported only 25 cases that led to campus disciplinary proceedings. In 2027-2028 alone, public high schools reported 800 rapes and 3,800 sexual battery incidents, the Office for Civil Rights reported.
2009: Colleges and universities reported 3,300 forcible sex offenses in 2009, according to the Office for Civil Rights. These were the tip of the iceberg — only an estimated 4%-8% of sexually assaulted college students reported it to campus officials.
Sexual assault, 2010s
2015: Research found that most student survivors of rape, sexual assault, or abuse suffer a drop in their grade point average and are more likely to leave school because of lack of support. Also that year, the editor of Rolling Stone Magazine retracted an explosive account of an alleged gang-rape at a University of Virginia fraternity house because of faulty reporting. The retraction provided new fuel for critics aiming to discredit rape allegations in general.
2011-2016: Penn State leaders fired Football Coach Joe Paterno and President Graham Spanier after police uncovered evidence they’d tolerated signs of child abuse by Assistant Coach Jerry Sandusky. Sandusky eventually was convicted of 45 counts of molesting 10 boys and sent to prison. Penn State paid a $2.4 million fine for Clery Act violations, $7.3 million in a jury judgement for firing a coach who blew the whistle on Sandusky, and $93 milion to 33 people sexually assaulted by Sandusky.
2017-2019: Faculty sexual misconduct led to some historically huge payouts by universities accused of turning a blind eye to the harassers they employed. The University of California, Berkeley, paid $1.7 million to one employee and $80,000 to a doctoral student. UC Santa Cruz agreed to pay $1.15 million to a student survivor. UC San Francisco paid $150,000 to another. The UC system fired fewer than half of the 47 employees found to have sexually assaulted students, colleagues, or patients, a San Francisco Chronicle analysis found. California State University campuses hit state taxpayers and insurers for another $440,500 in payouts on four campuses.
2019: A yearlong investigation by the Associated Press revealed a “hidden horror” of 17,000 sexual assaults by K-12 students against their peers over a four-year period, with attacks beginning as early as ages five and six.
2018: Michigan State University agreed to pay a whopping $500 million to settle claims by at least 250 girls and women against sports doctor Larry Nassar for sexual assault and harassment. The university also paid $4.5 million for Clery Act violations. A judge sentenced Nassar to 40-175 years in prison and more for child pornography.
2019: Dartmouth College in New Hampshire agreed to a $14 million settlement of a class-action suit by nine students alleging 15 years of faculty misconduct in one department.
Sexual assault, 2020s
2020: Claims that sports physician Robert E. Anderson sexually abused 800 or more students — mostly men — over decades cost the University of Michigan $10.7 million by this point, with more likely to come.
2021: After hundreds of students — again mostly men — came forward to report decades of rapes and fondling by Ohio State University athletics doctor Richard Strauss, university officials agreed to pay nearly $47 million to settle 185 of around 400 suits, with others ongoing. Also in 2021, the University of Southern California said it would pay $1.1 billion (yes, billion with a b) to hundreds of former patients of campus gynecologist George Tyndall who claimed they’d been sexually molested while the university did nothing to stop him.
And then…
My book ends at the 50th anniversary of Title IX in 2022. Despite efforts over decades that grew the movement against sexual violence and increased attention to sexual misconduct under Title IX, rates of campus sexual misconduct don’t seem to have decreased significantly. In a 2019 survey of 181,752 students by the Association of American Universities, 33% of undergraduates said that while in college they’d experienced nonconsensual sexual contact by force or inability to give consent or stop what was happening. Extrapolated to the 16.6 million undergraduates enrolled in 2018, that represents more than 5 million students in that year alone.
The outrage over what happened at Cornell is new, and yet timeless. It’s becoming part of history, and will add its influence to the story yet to come.
Comments (0)